I recently watched a wonderful TED talk* in which Chimamanda Adichie, an acclaimed writer, shared her views on how single stories create prejudices, stereotypes and false perceptions. I was deeply moved by what she said and it set me thinking about how many such single stories have skewed my perspective of things or worse still - how many such single stories I must have told!
In the recent past, I had joked in a large gathering about how my son, despite being born to Indian parents, rolls his "R"s and only speaks English; whereas I wouldn't speak in English until I was forced to do so in college and then later at work place. My self deprecating humor about having studied in Kendriya Vidyalaya schools being the main source of this difference in my son and me was grossly misunderstood and I now hear that its become a notion among some people here that KVites can't speak English.
My attempt at poking fun at myself misfired; and a misconception became their only story about KVs. And of course its all my fault!
Unlike most good (read expensive) private schools, KVs have students from all walks of life, their economic standing cutting across the entire cross section, multi-cultural and of course multi-lingual. In this setting, I was the "officer's daughter" since my father was one of the higher ranking government employees by the time I started going to school. Most other students were children of "factory workers" or "admin staff" and were naturally lesser mortals in the scheme of things. Our family and a few other classmates' families lived in better government houses classified as Type 5 (they have five rooms!) while the lesser mortals lived in much smaller Type 1, 2 and 3 houses. Overall I was much better off than most growing up around me. Though mostly unspoken, yet a great divide existed between the two kinds.
KV definitely taught me all the subjects that the Indian education boards regulate - science, math, history, geography, Hindi and of course English! In fact, it taught us quite well. It is no surprise that a lot of my friends, both my brothers, their batch mates and many more I get to know of are doing well in their lives. They are successful in their professions, financially stable and are certainly in the main stream of society. This despite their very humble start in some seemingly run down KV, in a satellite town of a Tier II Indian city, in the mid eighties. Education at a KV is good (certainly not the best!) and serves well to those it caters to. But, more importantly the aforementioned unique setting of a KV teaches you lessons about life. Lessons which private schools will never teach you. Here are some -
Play It Down - If I had to make friends in school I had to very self consciously play down my fathers' designation and all the tangible/intangible perks that came with being his daughter. And since I was the minority, breaking ice and building bridges in relationships always had to be my prerogative.
Fair Play - Much to my dismay and others' delight, we learned that fair play existed. Despite being an officer's daughter (oh! how I hated the tag), I never qualified for any event on Sport Day in all my school life. I was bad at it and that's all that mattered.
Relative Misery - While I always wanted my own girlie bike and hated my brother's hand-me-down boy bicycle, I realized I had classmates who would walk 4-5 km one way to school everyday, in all seasons. In fact, very often they would stop to fill water at our house (which was just a km from school) since they knew it was a long journey back home, under the scorching sun, at 3 PM. If you look around carefully, you'll see that your misery is always relatively smaller when compared to some others'.
Depreciation is Overrated - Not everything you own depreciates with the passage of time. I valued every single hand-me-down book and never fussed for crisp brand new ones because I had friends whose parents couldn't afford them all the books in one go at the start of the academic year.
Early Prudence - You don't have a school canteen. You don't have fancy vendors with kiosks, like the ones my city bred cousins boasted of. You don't have friends who can afford even the street vendors very often. What are you supposed to do? Well, I had a super-mom who happily packed a tiffin everyday. And for the most part I appreciated every bit(e) of it!
Defining Basics & Extravagance - I had just one pair of these boring brown shoes (Bata of course!) for all occasions. I really felt like my basics were not being met - until I noticed some school friends wearing our school uniform shoes when I ran into them at the market-place in the evening, or at b'day parties and even during the once a year community festivals.
These moments of truth were in my face and were too glaring to be denied. However, I would like to clarify that these haven't made me a pseudo-socialist. What a Kendriya Vidyalaya does to you is something more basic. Something much simpler. It genuinely prepares you for life ahead and in turn gives the world thousands of it's students that are level headed, value driven and sensitive to its environment.
*Here's the link to the TED talk -http://www.ted.com/talks/lang/eng/chimamanda_adichie_the_danger_of_a_single_story.html
13 comments:
Thats a wonderful article. I know exactly how you feel. Having travelled accross the country throughout my academic years I too have been through similar situations. I used to feel terribly embarrased when the 'staff car' dropped us to school. I had utmost respect for the students who despite their financial hardships made it to the top of the class or remarked in sports!
Hey Anu !!
Not exactly sure what triggered this post..but I thoroughly enjoyed your writing !
Well,I completely understand where you're coming..as i am equally sensitive about my schooling.
Afterall,its been a major contributor to "who i am".
Three cheers to our "Alma Mater" !!
Hi Blogger!! Kudos to the writer in you!! Knowing partly what prompted you to write this, all have to say is you dont owe anyone an explaination for your life instances. Also i know no matter what, you cant get this across to the person in reference here. Still its nice to know you have great respect for where you come from and appreciate the things that shaped you into the person you are....and thats the most important of it all! Cheers
From the bottom of your heart!! Its very well written.Having studied at the KVs all my life too, my experience has been slightly different. English was the school language and I learnt it quickly in class V after shifting to South India from the North. Also the place dictated the students in the school!! different in Pune/Bangalore from one of the smaller towns!! they have been good schools, not the best but very Good!!
my Anu is really grown up. written well. i can assure you have not missed anything in life nevertheless it has made you a better person. Having feeling for less privileged keep you balanced. We do miss on english and good quality of education particularly in small town KV schools but they do prepares us to meet challenges in our life
very well written.HATS OFF!! you know how well i can realte to all this.
I write here as a very proud KV-ite; out of my 13 schools, 08 were KVs. But I do not write this in defence of Central Schools (as they were originally called); strong institutions do not demand that validation.
To understand the ethos of KVs, it's imperative we know why they were formed. But that's not the "central" point right now, so we'll skip that.
What I would like to highlight, however, is the oft ignored fact that KVs are not Hindi medium schools. Not that there's anything wrong with vernacular schools, but ‘KV equals Hindi’ is just a myth. KVs are bilingual, and isn't that a wonderful choice to have! So for every circle of latitude, I know there is an "akshaansh rekha", for every colony, there is an “upanivesh”, and for every republic, there is a “ganarajya”.
After the Army and the Hindi film industry, to an extent, if there is an organisation that's truly secular to its bone, it is the KV Sangathan. (Here I talk of the Indian idea of secularism, not the western one characterised by the French.) Anyway, KVs are a wonderful melting pot of not just people from different regions and tongues, but different classes as well: as you have wonderfully illustrated in your post. It is something that an outsider may not fully comprehend, because most other educational institutions cater to a homogeneous demographic. In a KV, something as basic as keeping your uniform “uniform” may take tact on your parents’ part. You know what I mean…
It is primarily due to this disparity among KV students that Hindi is the primary means of communication. It’s just a cultural thing, not to be taken at face value. There are so many funny anecdotes that come to my mind right now… Like the time I won an inter-collegiate Creative Writing contest in the first year of college (where, incidentally, participants had come from the English Departments of some of the premier colleges in India), and one amazed relative asked me, “Oh, you KNOW English?!”
Hello Dear,
what a fabulous blog entry. Something we all go through and think about but never speak about it !!!!
School plays a very important part in WHO you become eventually. Life gives us options at every stage and we are the outcome of the path we chose at every stage.
Well Said! Love you blogs... You have the talent to write and narrate them so beautifully and in perfect order... Really it was a very sensitive topic and I agree with you... Most of KVites have done very well and are now well established in all parts of the world... I m really proud of being a Kvite... Keep writing more as I enjoy them...
Quite a thought provoking and a very fact of life written piece.
Good read, fav.. I'm also from KV
Post a Comment